SHADOW EXCLUSIVE:
EYEWITNESS REPORT FROM THE
ZAPATISTA REVOLUTION
By Bill Weinberg
[NEWS FLASH!! As the SHADOW goes to press (2/10), we have just received word that Mexican government troops are moving on the Zapatis
A year has come and gone since the Indian rebel movement called the Zapatista Army of National Liberation (EZLN) launched its New Years Day 1994 uprising in the southern Mexican state of Chiapas. As 1994 came to a close, this poorest and most Indian of Mexican states was back at the brink of war. A ceasefire was brokered at the last minute, but the new President Ernesto Zedillo and his long-ruling Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI) face both financial crisis in the wake of December's dramatic peso collapse, and a fast-growing revolutionary movement throughout the Mexican south.
"I consider myself only an instrument of the people, who want a legitimate government," says Amado Avendaño, the self-proclaimed "rebel governor" of Chiapas, from his improvised office in an occupied building of the National Indian Institute (INI) in the Highland city of San Cristobal de Las Casas.
Pine needles cover the floor, and the rebel governor's Indian supporters have set up a small altar in the reception area, with candles and copal incense. "So I am here," says Avendaño, who still wears a patch over one eye from his pre-election auto crash which he calls an assassination attempt. "At the moment I no longer have that support, I am ready to go back home and continue to publish my newspaper.
Avendaño published El Tiempo, San Cristobal's small but feisty daily, before announcing his gubernatorial candidacy with the Party of the Democratic Revolution (PRD), which has emerged as the first serious left opposition to the PRI's entrenched 65 year hegemonic rule.
The August elections brought the PRI's Eduardo Robledo to power, but a "Popular Electoral Tribunal" made up of representatives from Indian and cam-pesino groups declared the results frau-dulent after their independent investigation. Upon Robledo's assumption of power on December 8, the EZLN declared the ceasefire, which had held since January, broken. 40,000 federal army troops poured in to Chiapas, fortifying the roadblocks surround-ing the Zapatistas' stronghold in the remote jungle known as the Lacandon Selva.
Seemingly trapped, on December 19, the Zapatistas surprised the nation by filtering out of the Selva--and through the army's net--along remote mountain trails, and announcing their presence in 38 of Chiapas' 111 municipalities, most-ly in the Highlands. Blockading roads, and occupying the municipal palace in the village of Simojovel, the Zapatistas declared the 38 municipalities "in rebellion" and loyal to the "rebel transition government" of Amado Avendaño.
As the army moved in on the rebel positions, the Zapatistas abandoned their roadblocks and disappeared into the local population. Tanks and troops occupied the Highland villages, often at the ostensible invitation of the munici-pal authorities. But the PRIista municipal governments often have administra-tive control only over the village centers. In the surrounding outlying peasant communities, real territorial control lies with the Indian and campesino independent (i.e. not government-controlled) organizations, which generally support Avendaño and the EZLN.
Since last January's Zapatista uprising, these groups have united in the State Council of Indian & Campesino Organizations (CEOIC), and launched a statewide campaign of land occupations. The federal government, in an effort to buy peace, has agreed to reimburse the big ranchers, who make up the traditional economic elite of Chiapas, for their squatted lands. But the ranchers' organizations are demanding a government crackdown on the occupations and have openly announced that they are putting the money into arms. Violent conflict between CEOIC militants and the Guardias Blancas, the private goon squads of the cattle aristocracy, con-tinues to shake the state. CEOIC charges that the landowners are organ-izing "death squads."
Since December 8, CEOIC has de-clared five "pluri-ethnic autonomous re-gions" in Chiapas. In a state long torn by violent divisions between Indians and mestizos, the CEOIC is demanding a lo-cal self government which includes and respects all ethnic groups. Many outlying hamlets have declared themselves self governing "New Municipalities," breaking from the PRI controlled muni-cipal governments of the village centers. Avendaño and the EZLN have recog-nized these Autonomous Regions and New Municipalities.
Avendaño, who has appointed an Autonomy Council made up of Indian leaders, says, "The Tojolobales in Trinitaria, Las Margaritas and Ocosingo want their own laws, in their own language and tradition. The Choles, in the northern zone of the state, want their own system of justice in their own territory." All of the seven councils the rebel governor has appointed include Indians--this in a state where the impoverished Indian majority has always been excluded from political power.
Robledo, attempting to defuse the situation, has officially left the PRI. The federal government has declared the official agrarian reform, terminated elsewhere in the country in preparation for the anticipated privatization of communal ejido lands under NAFTA, back on the agenda in Chiapas, where it was never effectively applied in the first place due to the power of the local aristocracy.
But it may not be enough to buy peace. "Nothing has changed in Chia-pas," says Avendaño. "So the Zapatistas have reason to be in the same state of war."
On December 19, San Cristobal's Bishop Samuel Ruiz began a hunger strike--which he called a religious fast--for peace. Ruiz, long a champion of Chiapas' Indians, brokered the abortive dialogue between the Zapatistas and the federal government at his cathedral last March. Now, the EZLN has rejected the Multi-Party Peace Commission convened by President Zedillo as bogus, and demanded government recognition of the National Intermediation Commis-sion (CONAI) convened by Ruiz as a condition for declaring a ceasefire and returning to the table. On December 24, the government blinked and agreed to recognize CONAI.
Ruiz, fasting in the cathedral, was visited by both high-level government delegations and groups of supportive Indians from Highland villages who drum and dance in his honor. The government troops which had penetrated into Zapatista territory on the edge of the Selva were withdrawn, and the EZLN responded by declaring a six-day truce beginning January 1. After ten days of tension and paranoia, Chiapas appeared, for the moment at least, to be back from the brink.
After nearly three weeks, Bishop Ruiz ended his fast. On January 15, the EZLN announced an indefinite cease-fire, and Interior Secretary Esteban Moctezuma was helicoptered into a secret location in the Lacandon Selva for the first talks on the possibility of a new dialogue with the Zapatistas.
But the crisis is far from over. "It's a grave situation," says Marina Patricia of the San Cristobal Diocese's Fray Bartolemé de Las Casas Human Rights Center. She says the center has documented 130 human rights violations in Chiapas in 1994 after the January ceasefire. They include killings, rapes, torture and arbitrary detention, mostly committed by the army or Guardias Blancas against local Indians. "There have been no serious investigations," says Patricia. Furthermore, in many cases, such as that of two Tzeltal women raped at a military roadblock in Altamirano, victims are willing to report violations to the Las Casas Center, but too intimidated to pursue the cases in the legal system.
Meanwhile, the left opposition is challenging the installation of PRI governors in the neighboring states of Oaxaca, Veracruz and Tabasco. From December 2 through 8, the central square in Oaxaca City was occupied by thousands of pro-democracy dissidents from the PRI-controlled teachers' union demanding the resignation of the PRI's Governor Diodoro Carrasco. This followed a November strike in which teachers occupied the city's airport, and two were mysteriously killed. Oaxaca's dissident Section 22 of the National Education Workers Union (SNTE) has forged strong links to independent Indian and campesino organizations in both Oaxaca and Chiapas, and has participated in cross-country marches in solidar-ity with the Zapatistas.
Pro-democracy dissident oil workers in Tabasco have for the past year been holding blockades at the gates of the government petrol plants along the Gulf Coast to press their demand for the right to organize trade unions outside the PRI-controlled bureaucracy. They have recently formed an alliance with local campesinos and fishermen concerned with the ecological degradation of their lands and waters by the oil in-stallations. More recently, they joined forces with PRD militants to demand the resignation of the PRI's Governor Roberto Madrazo, who they claim was fraudulently elected. PRD activists hal-ted traffic and staged hunger strikes in Villahermosa, Tabasco's state capital. But on January 12, after Zedillo announced a new political pact with the PRD which broached the possibility of new elections for Tabasco under more democratic rules, local PRIistas took to the streets of Villahermosa and a pitched brawl with PRD supporters ensued. Bricks flew and cars were overturned.
The street battle in Villahermosa reflected national tensions. Tabasco is the heart of Mexico's oil industry, and both the PRD and hardliners within the PRI have voiced grave concerns about Zedillo's pledge to use Mexico's oil as collateral for Washington's $40 billion loan guarantees to resuscitate the crippled peso. The state oil monopoly PEMEX is a potent symbol of national-ism, and was therefore overlooked in the wave of privatization of state com-panies initiated by President Carlos Salinas in preparation for NAFTA. Now Salinas, whose ambition was to head the new World Trade Organization, has been brought up on treason charges by the PRD for sabotaging the Mexican economy. Veracruz oil workers have joined those in Tabasco in strikes and blockades of the PEMEX plant gates, and the new paranoia over PEMEX pri-vatization lends urgency to their de-mands for workers' control of the indus-try.
The EZLN have added the anti-PRI struggles in Oaxaca, Tabasco and Veracruz to their lists of demands, and there have been reports that Zapatista troops have penetrated Tabascan territory across Chiapas' northern border. There is speculation that Zedillo's new political accord could also mean new elec-tions for Chiapas-a central Zapatista demand. But the backlash seen on Janu-ary 12 from the Tabasco PRIistas is like-ly to seem tame in comparison to that from Chiapas' reactionary cattle oligarchy.
Subcomandante Marcos, the Zapatis-tas' mysterious masked military leader, charged in a December communique that Kaibiles, the elite Guatemalan counter-insurgency troops, had pene-trated the Lacandon Selva from across the border with the secret cooperation of the Mexican federal army. The Kaibi-les had carried out the blood-drenched repression in the Guatemalan Highlands which sent a flood of Indian refugees into the Lacandon Selva in the 1980s. But Marcos concluded that:
"Their presence does not worry us, because the EZLN is not a traditional guerrilla. It controls its territory and considers itself a regular army. I think the federal army realizes that they can't use Guatemalan-style counter insurgency. Because they know that they con-front a regular army. They know that they do not face a guerrilla that oper-ates in the mountains, but a guerrilla that operates everywhere."
Since December 19, no journalist has been able to reach Marcos. But on January 18, this writer contacted Major Moises behind Zapatista lines at Guada-lupe Tepeyac in the Lacandon Selva. Moises, along with Marcos and Comandante Tacho of the Indigenous Revolutionary Clandestine Committee, the EZLN's General Command, was part of the Zapatista delegation that met with Interior Minister Esteban Moctezuma three days earlier. Like Marcos, Moises has taken to smoking a pipe; unlike Marcos, he is clearly an Indian--a Tzeltal.
Moises expressed skepticism about the government's good faith in the tentatively renewed peace process. A condition of the meeting with Esteban Moctezuma, for instance, had been withdrawal of federal army troops from the villages they had occupied. Moises pointed out that the government had merely complied with the letter of the agreement--as the army troops withdrew, federal judicial police took their place in Simojovel and other villages.
In Guadalupe Tepeyac, the EZLN is the open authority, and Marcos' analysis is self evident. But aren't the Highland communities more divided? "No, it's the same," says Moises. "In the Highland communities there need to be better tactics to carry out the orders the troops receive from the Comandancia. But the organization of the EZLN is the same in the Highlands as it is here. It is not a guerilla, it is a regular army."
"It is a process," Moises continues. "We will follow what the population says. When they say it is time to announce our presence to the municipal authorities, it is done. We don't want to impose our position. We follow what the people want. They are aware of their own situation--the balance of power with the ranchers. They will know the right moment. And then we will be the authority in the Highlands too."
ShadowMain Shadow #35 Publications Subscribe to The Shadow
MediaFilter Artists on MediaFilter CHAOS